a dude that likes gaming and tech (especially Linux) aro/ace

  • 1 Post
  • 81 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: November 6th, 2023

help-circle



  • To be clear, I still think pirating non-megacorp productions is bad, I just don’t think we should conflate IP and property rights, and just evaluate whether it’d be a good thing or not to expand IP law to cover AI training.

    Which it wouldn’t, since expanding IP law has never been good for the little guy, making companies have to pay to train AI on stuff won’t make them pay the artists, they’ll just pay the record labels and social media platforms, which will all have updated their EULA’s to retroactively give them the right to use everything on there to train AI. None of those dollars will go to artists. The only thing that would change is more money changing hands at the top and removing competition in the AI sphere.


  • Yeah but IP law has never protected the little guy, it’s only ever been used to punch down. I’m not against copyright law, to be clear, just how wide and nebulous IP law is.

    The current way that creating something not only gives you the right to restrict the copying of it (which I support) for like 100 years (too long imo) but also the right to:

    1. decide how it’s viewed, control what people can do with it even if they don’t share it. (what format it’s in, what it can be displayed on, etc)
    2. decide what people can do with ideas inside of it. (e.g nobody being allowed to add a character from another series into their own.
    3. restrict the sharing of snippets, like in a review.

    is way too much to me, I don’t think that people should be allowed to have so much control over something they put out into the world. To me, you should be able to keep the right to copy your work for, say, 10-20 years and the right to the ideas in it for a shorter time. The fact that superman still isn’t public domain is absurd.

    The current system only empowers large companies. When was the last time someone successfully sued a big company for one of the numbered points, versus how many times the opposite has happened?

    I don’t like calling piracy theft because it conflates property rights, “basic” copyright and IP rights. It’s obviously still copyright infringement and bad, if it hurts a small developer or artist, which, incidentally, I don’t do. But I pay them because I want to support them, not out of respect for the current state of IP law.

    All that to say why I don’t see a problem with training anything on AI, since that falls under point 1 for me. Also, banning it would only make every social media platform add “we reserve the rights to use anything uploaded for AI” to their EULA, and nothing would change, except that open weight models disappear.















  • It’s natural because we would all die if it weren’t, but you’re avoiding my main argument. I said that the sympathy comes from “this person cannot live a dignified life because of situation” and the situation being bringing another person into the world.

    Your Ferrari analogy fails because in that case you want “luxury” but in the child case they already have a child but you can’t afford to live, instead of being able to live but not having a luxury they want. I would feel sympathy for someone who, say, bought a luxury then lost their job, and are now having a really hard time because they no longer have any savings.

    Also, don’t you think it’s a bit sad that having children, something people have famously done since forever, is now something you can be priced out of? (Also where I live the government does subsidize weight loss, if it’s bad enough to really impact your life)

    edit: lmao dude stopped responding the second someone made an argument he couldn’t just wave away with the same premade argument