• 1 Post
  • 76 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 9th, 2026

help-circle



  • Do tell me in what way the farmers and industry workers have any control of literally anything in North Korea?

    And how can you say welfare isn’t socialism? Much of the point is to provide a safety net so none of your country men become destitute. Oligarchy is what marxism was meant to stop, and yet it is maintained in both countries. North Korea doesn’t even bother to hide that it is a straight up dictatorship other than adding; Democrat, peoples, and Republic to their name. None of which actually represents reality.

    Look at the difference between Norway’s prisons and those of those other 3 countries. That alone should tell you who the good guys and bad guys are. They try to help people as opposed to punishing them. That raises the quality of life for all individuals in the country. Hiding them away in a prison for talking about ideas? That’s not socialism in any way, shape or form and all three of those countries do that.

    Maybe you should talk to more MLs with a stance that you’re coming with an open but more skeptical mind. Erase what you thought you knew about socialism, and really pay attention to what they say. They’ll use circular logic, non sequiturs, and hasty generalizations. In fact you, yourself used the fallacy of appealing to popularity. If your argument doesn’t stand up here, then I should go where all the MLs go so they can gang up on me. Your argument should be strong enough to stand up anywhere, especially somewhere with as many socialists as Lemmy has.


  • Well, both Russia and China are heirarchical. That alone tells you that not everybody is on the same footing, which is the whole point. That the president is no better than the peasant. But peasants shouldn’t exist in a truly marxist modern country.

    Beyond that, I don’t really know much about how chinas voting works but we all know Russias doesn’t. That doesn’t bode well for being championed as a country with marxist ideals. MLs just need SOMEONE to champion, so they site Russia and China, sometimes even north korea. It’s an absurd argument because none of them are communist or marxist or even socialist. They may have some socialist areas like healthcare, but not even as much as Norway.

    Believe in ML, fine. I won’t argue that the ideas are wrong. But those countries do not fit in with ML ideals. That’s why MLs get ignored, because they ignore their own ideals to put countries on a pedestal when they don’t follow them. It’s a lot like Christians voting for someone like trump, who blatantly does unchristian things. It’s not just that their beliefs are wrong, but their beliefs are at odds with their beliefs.