publicado de forma cruzada desde: https://hexbear.net/post/9826368
I wrote this analysis originally as a comment in this post to reply to this other comment. Feel free to discuss my analysis, I would love to get a richer outlook.
There’s a lot of talk about Soviet agriculture being inefficient, and it’s a partial truth stated as a fact when reality is a lot more nuanced:
By the 1970s, the USSR and the USA were producing comparable amounts of grain, around 200 million tonnes of grain per year depending on the harvest (USSR a bit less, USA a bit more). In the USA, this was produced by an agricultural workforce of some 3-4 million workers, or about 4% of the labour force. In the USSR, this production was carried out by 27 million workers, or 25% of the labour force, data according to the official statistical bureaus of both countries. When this is discussed in western literature, it’s attributed to “chronic inefficiencies in the Soviet agriculture” without any further analysis, but the lack of analysis hides the truth:
Starting with the US: a very significant amount of the labor was unaccounted completely in the official statistics. In a family of 4, if the father worked the fields registered as an agricultor while his wife and children “helped” him, this was accounted only as one worker, where de-facto there were four workers. Additionally, a great share of the labor in US agriculture is performed by unregistered migrant workers who are paid under the table and don’t count in official statistics.
In contrast, the kolkhoz agricultural system in the USSR of collective agrarian ownership counted as employees all workers not only in the fields, but also workers such as cooks feeding the workers (unpaid female labor in the US by contrast), mechanics fixing the machinery (instead of outsourcing the process to urban factories), accountants… So how do we solve this accounting difference problem which seems so insurmountable? We could, for example, compare the total rural population in both countries, since rural life revolves around agriculture, especially so in the last century.
The evolution of rural population in the USA and the USSR is as follows: from 1920 to 1970, the percentage of rural dwellers in the USA went from 49% to 26%; in the USSR it went from 82% to 38%. This already showcases the largest difference: the Soviet agriculture was still developing due to the later industrialization of the USA, and it was doing it QUICK, whereas by the 1970s the USA’s rural population had already stabilized as a result of earlier industrialization. Additionally, this figure portrays how the difference in total agrarian labor wasn’t as large, not a tenfold factor (mostly artificial due to comparison with entirely different accounting systems) but more like a 50% larger rural workforce in the USSR compared to the USA. Now, let’s examine this difference:
First and foremost, a huge factor is climate. The climate in the grain-growing steppes of the former USSR is much more unreliable, with shorter growing seasons, colder weather, and a larger variability in rainfall compared to the temperate grain-growing regions of the USA. Agricultural production varied much more wildly and unpredictably on a year-to-year basis in the USSR, which in the former Russian empire had led to massive famines which the Soviet society forever eliminated after the 1930s.
Likely the other largest factor is the availability of services in rural areas. In the USSR, rural areas had incomparable access to healthcare, education, arts, culture and entertainment compared to the USA. Anyone who knows anything about US rural regions knows it’s essentially devoid of any form of any of those services, whereas rural Soviets enjoyed access to them.
(example of an abandoned Dom Kultury)
For reference, in modern Russia they are constantly closing polyclinics, maternity wards, schools, and there is literally none of the entertainment or culture left, and my girlfriend tells me how in the village where she comes from, now the closest hospital is above an hour away by car where they used to have a polyclinic and maternity ward in the neighboring rural centre. It is simply incomprehensible to people like me from the capitalist west to imagine a rural life rich in arts, healthcare, education, culture, sports and entertainment. Practically every town with above a few thousand inhabitants had a “Дом культуры” (dom kultury, culture house) vibrant with poetry clubs, art classes, theater companies… Children also could enjoy an immense amount of positive activities by belonging to the communist youths of the pioneers and the komsomol, so they weren’t isolated in their homes as American children are (even in cities). Which brings me to the last point:
Since rural life in the USSR wasn’t utter garbage, people didn’t have such strong incentives to move to cities by the 1970s when the USSR had almost fully industrialized. When you were guaranteed your job at the kolkhoz with a decent wage regardless of crops that year, you had land to yourself to grow your own food, you had entertainment, art, culture and sports, and your children had education, fun activities, friends and healthcare, people could (and did) just stay in villages in the USSR. Farmers could work 8h and go to the dom kultur or to spend the evening with their children, unlike petit-bourgeois farmers in the west who simultaneously say it’s the hardest job in the world (they do work 12h a day 7 days a week very often), while simultaneously taking that as something to be proud of and not as them exploiting themselves for a bigger wage next year.
So yeah, did the USian agricultural worker produce more grain per year, and did a hectare of USian soil produce more grain per year, when compared to the USSR? Yes. Is this simply to be taken as a random fact proving the inefficiencies of Soviet economy? Absolutely fucking not, and I’d 1000% rather have lived as a Soviet agricultural worker in the 1970s than as a Yank landowner.
You know, I think this analysis is really interesting. I do wonder how life in the USSR truly was, and I’m quite sad to know I’ll never find out, but, in a country where half the population is illiterate, two thirds can’t afford a yearly vacation, and everything has been in complete freefall for years, I do yearn for a competent state, a guaranteed living wage, apartment, healthcare, and more.
I highly recommend This Soviet World, by Anna Louise Strong. She wrote it in 1936, so around the time of the first Five Year Plan. Reading it today, it’s clear that the fall of the USSR was an immense tragedy. The book touches on all manner of Soviet life, without requiring the reader to know a single thing about Marxism.
Thank you. I should maybe mention that I am quite familiar with life under failed socialism. Many people around me have lived through the final years of the Romanian Socialist Republic, a regime which starved its people from 1982 onwards. However, I’ve never read anything about early soviet life.
Ceaușescu serves a good lesson on why relying on the west for loans and support is a death sentence. In order to repay western loans, he enforced austerity, leading to severe rationing. He tried to balance and navigate the sino-soviet split, but ultimately did not succeed in doing so. He was legitimately a mostly good force up until the 70s or so, before the austerity of the 80s.
Wanna remark that while the austerity was fucked up, the loans did modestly succeed in building up the capital of the country and increasing productivity, and from what I gather by the late 1980s they were finished paying and Romania stopped being in debt. What sunk Romania into economic turmoil after that was the capitalist shock therapy, not the loans themselves (though they were not a good move, the same happened in Poland).
These loans also serve to point out the level of political independence that existed in the eastern block. Contrary to the popular belief of the satellite states being directed from Moscow, the loans in Poland and Romania were entirely against the opinion of the Kremlin leadership, and they were still carried out without the approval of the USSR.
Good points! Merely wanted to state the death sentence that relying on the west was, not the pursuit of loans themselves. Austerity did genuinely contribute to turning the people against Ceaușescu, and socialism in general. The dissolution of socialism was far worse than the austerity, but the austerity was a bungle that contributed to wanting it.
Living in the ashes of his mistakes makes me wonder. Romania, even then, was not a country free from class divide. Hypocrisy ran rampant just as it does now, and living conditions are generally higher than at the end of 1989. Still, our culture has disappeared. Art is no more in Romania. Probably the best example is the film industry. It’s full of nothing but trash. Cheap comedy films that are not funny and recycle the same jokes.
Meanwhile, socialist Romanian movies are still celebrated. One of the best examples is “Brigada Diverse”. A series of three movies, with over 20 being planned but cancelled by the government for their jokes upon the police. It features three crooks who get involved in bigger crimes accidentally, and are in constant conflict with the police. Since you recommended me a book, I think it’s only fair I recommend you a piece of media from the golden years of the RSR. The movies were made in 1970 and 1971.
Thanks, I’ll check it out! Interestingly, socialist art is generally very high quality, because it’s typically divorced from the profit motive. Art is made for its own sake, and to build up the collective culture, rather than to profit off of maximum sales.
From what I gather (feel free to correct me), Romania was almost entirely preindustrial before the Soviets liberated it from fascism. Industrial capital grew exponentially from late 1940s onward, developing a big chemical industry by the 1970s, with the Soviet model of extensive industrial growth bringing massive economic boost and the urbanization of Romania, leaving behind its preindustrial past in record time.
Capital growth was still sought after that by the central government even after it became harder, so they got into loans with western banks. The capital growth did partially but not fully succeed, leading to modest industrial output growth, so in order to repay the debts, austerity was implemented. However, by the late 1980s, the debt was almost entirely repaid, and only due to the dissolution of socialism did the economy implode.
Inflation wasn’t a serious issue during socialism, when suddenly after the arrival of capitalism the country’s industry was dismantled, inflation skyrocketed, and the economy was destroyed for like a decade (as happened in all the former Eastern Block except for the Baltics, Poland and Czech Republic).
Population hasn’t stopped dropping since 1990s due to brain drain, suicide rates, defunding of healthcare, lower birth rates, higher criminality and violent crime, and lower guarantees of employment with endemic unemployment.
Rural areas have been defunded, forcing the people to move from formerly small towns and rural estates to larger cities where the financialized economy is centered, which itself drives up massively the price of housing.
So yeah, honest question, would you say my analysis is accurate (as a Spaniard)? Would you say you’re living the consequences of the socialist economy, or the consequences of its dismantling? To which degree can you attribute the crashing economy of the 90s onwards to the socialist form of government?
Additionally, since you mention culture: we are used to focusing on mass-media when it comes to culture because in capitalism consumption is the main way to access culture. However, in some socialist countries of the Eastern Block, so-called “culture houses” were established in most towns and villages, where workers organized clubs ranging from sports to art, literature and theatre, therefore creating their own culture instead of being limited to consuming what appears in mass-media. Did such “culture houses” exist in Romania to a large extent during Socialism?
Your analysis on Romanian was spot on. I don’t know Romania was liberated, but I also can’t find a better word for it. WW2 was a dark period, with the ruling class switching sides by the day. We did however have a strong oil industry even during the war, making Romania a somewhat valuable target.
The debt had been repaid, but it was all too late. I don’t blame the people who rose up against the oppression, as the state also heavily tightened its grip in the decade, to quiet dissenting voices.
Still, the truth remains that the oligarchs that followed sold every factory, every fleet, any mode of production that we had, making us a slave to globalism.
Although living conditions are, on average, better now, things are quickly getting worse. This country has no future, it would seem. It is plagued by racism, homophobia, transphobia, a severe lack of education and a mindset of pure ignorance and arrogance, powered by Orthodox Christianity.
To answer your final question, quite a fair bit. This stunt of taking Western loans and dealing with the consequences caused great damage to the socialist cause in Romania and enabled our first presidents to rob us fully.
Thank you very much for your response, I don’t often get to discuss the topic of Romania with a Romanian that’s not a diehard pro-EU imperialist or a reactionary queerphobe (it seems to be the two dominating political stances in most of Europe) and your perspective enriches my analysis.
I added a last paragraph to my previous comment that you didn’t see when responding, would you be so kind to reply to it?


(example of an abandoned Dom Kultury)
