• 挂路灯人@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    If it was democracy, that’s what we’d call it. But we are not talking about democracy. The post is quite explicit about the fact that after a socialist revolution and before ‘true democracy’ comes a ‘dictatorship of the proletariat’, which is different.

    This is your warped view not reality. Communists do not talk of class dictatorship as separate from democracy but the base upon which it is built. It answers the question of democracy for who. The dictatorship of the proletariat is essentially short hand for democracy for the masses, repression for the bourgeoisie. Just as the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie is democracy for the bourgeoisie and charades and repression for the masses.

    My grandparents were workers in the GDR. They were part of the proletariat, they didn’t have a say. That’s ‘dictatorship of the proletariat’. A government run by ‘socialists’ with a higher standard of living than that of the general population.

    See this isn’t true just off the bat. But I don’t really want to relitigate that with you as it’s entirely irrelevant to the point at hand.

    The fact is, you have a preconception of what certain words mean and it is stopping you from grasping what’s actually being said.

    I could talk at length about my direct experience with the dictatorship of the proletariat in China and how the people’s voices and wishes are weaved in at every level from direct elections at town, city and county levels to the CPPCC, ACFTU, government hotline like 12345 and mandated representation for minorities etc. versus how the bourgeoisie are outright banned from people’s committee and congresses but it’s not at all relevant to the theoretical point at hand here that you repeatedly look directly in the eyes before casting aside to continue hammering on a strawman of your misconceptions.

    It is natural for a liberal to speak of “democracy” in general; but a Marxist will never forget to ask: “for what class?” Everyone knows, for instance (and Kautsky the “historian” knows it too), that rebellions, or even strong ferment, among the slaves in ancient times at once revealed the fact that the ancient state was essentially a dictatorship of the slave owners. Did this dictatorship abolish democracy among, and for, the slaveowners? Everybody knows that it did not.

    […]

    If we are not to mock at common sense and history, it is obvious that we cannot speak of “pure democracy” as long as different classes exist; we can only speak of class democracy. (Let us say in parenthesis that “pure democracy” is not only an ignorant phrase, revealing a lack of understanding both of the class struggle and of the nature of the state, but also a thrice-empty phrase, since in communist society democracy will wither away in the process of changing and becoming a habit, but will never be “pure” democracy.)

    “Pure democracy” is the mendacious phrase of a liberal who wants to fool the workers. History knows of bourgeois democracy which takes the place of feudalism, and of proletarian democracy which takes the place of bourgeois democracy.

    Lenin, The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky