This conversation plays out hundreds of times a day, but (thankfully) only a handful of those involve me: Person: “I have [problem].” Cryptography nerd: “Oh, you probably want to …
I take issue with a common argument about security folks. And that is a narrow view about the threat actors. Google’s 24/7 location tracking of every Android user is perfectly ok in that view. And when Signal pushes you to that ecosystem is perfectly valid and ok as well.
I’m currently using Molly (unofficial signal fork) that I acquired via Accrescent on GrapheneOS, and I haven’t had telemetry issues.
There’s also a desktop client that doesn’t interface with Google whatsoever.
I do agree that the “default installation” method through Google Play is problematic, but I don’t think advocating the Signal project as a gateway communications app is a bad thing on the whole (and even default Signal is far superior to SMS and WhatsApp with on-par setup in my opinion).
Matrix/XMPP is not a bad project by any means, but I don’t think I’d be able to successfully convince my family to set it up (while I can just have both available and use signal with them as needed)
I take issue with a common argument about security folks. And that is a narrow view about the threat actors. Google’s 24/7 location tracking of every Android user is perfectly ok in that view. And when Signal pushes you to that ecosystem is perfectly valid and ok as well.
Those arguments just don’t sit well with me.
I’m currently using Molly (unofficial signal fork) that I acquired via Accrescent on GrapheneOS, and I haven’t had telemetry issues.
There’s also a desktop client that doesn’t interface with Google whatsoever.
I do agree that the “default installation” method through Google Play is problematic, but I don’t think advocating the Signal project as a gateway communications app is a bad thing on the whole (and even default Signal is far superior to SMS and WhatsApp with on-par setup in my opinion).
Matrix/XMPP is not a bad project by any means, but I don’t think I’d be able to successfully convince my family to set it up (while I can just have both available and use signal with them as needed)