• 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 31st, 2023

help-circle
  • After the October 7 attack I was very pro isreal. Of course it’s totally unacceptable for a neighbor to enter one’s territory and kill hundreds of innocent civilians. You can’t commit such an act of terrorism without consequences. However I have seen that the Israeli invasion has been all but moral and the use of the word genocide feels more and more justified. It has gone way over board and I have staunchly become anti isreal. The war was supposed to be a war on Hamas but the innocent civilians in Gaza have had to bear with unbelievable suffering which I no longer believe justifies the war.


  • Indeed. Many of the cases reported on in media are extreme. For example that woman who sued because glyphosate caused her to have a miscarriage. She dropped a whole container of roundup all over her body. That’s an extremely different case than the parts per billion found in food at the grocery store. I like to compare it to household bleach. The one handling the bleach has to be very careful because it’s dangerous in its raw form. But no one should have to be afraid of wearing clothes washed in bleach the correct way.

    Many of the animal studies on glyphosate put either large amounts of it in their food or as one study did, literally sprayed it on the rats faces once per day. The only conclusion that can be drawn by that is that the one spraying it has to take caution not to spray it on themselves.


  • No that’s not it at all. The proposal is to keep the same process but allow pesticides to be approved indefinitely until a law is passed banning it. Currently a pesticide is approved for a certain time and after that time the approval expires and the substance has to be proved to be safe and reevaluated once again. For most pesticides this period is around 3-5 years. What this means is that every 5 years or so every pesticide has to go through this enormous and very costly bureaucratic process once again. Some more niche pesticides have lost their approval because the cost of going through the process once again is larger than the pesticide is paying out in sales. This system also leads to some weird situations because every pesticide bottle has a date on it. What happens is that even when the pesticide is reapproved the old bottles are still made illegal once the date runs out. If a farmer has old bottles at home with the old date on it he has to order new labels for them. I know this process very well because I send out these new labels all the time.

    Some however would say that this constant process of revaluation of every single pesticide 1-2 times every decade is good as the reevaluation can account for any new science that has come out but the fact is that it’s also extremely expensive and limits what can cost effectively be put on the market, especially for niche crops. No one wants to release a quinoa specific pesticide for example because the cost of reapplying every 3-5 years (common time interval for niche pesticides) is too high compared to the amount of quinoa grown in the EU. Another example is triticale which is a very productive grain but in my own country it has very low adoption because no pesticides are approved for it and no one wants to release pesticides for it because the land area grown for triticale is today too low. Chicken and egg situation.

    However I’m extremely biased here because I’m so damn sick of sending out new labels all the time.