• 0 Posts
  • 14 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 6th, 2023

help-circle






  • Idk who’s arguing society is more prosperous in the housing department now than it was 60 years ago. You’re conflating a very large set of metrics with one paired correlation. I would argue housing is getting undeniably worse for most people as a percentage of their net income and the quality that amount of money buys them.

    So even if you include the rates of home ownership, you need to account for the size of those homes, the quality of those homes, the debt those people are in (as you said, “house poor”). Ownership is not the single end-all metric, the real metric would be the power people have over their housing which I have no doubt is at a nearly all time low - hence why everyone rents, why those rentals are worse and smaller than they’ve ever been, and more expensive then they’ve ever been.

    I’m explicitly arguing that housing should not be an investment. Housing should be affordable, that is a fundamental goal of society. We don’t have stocks in food such that food should get more expensive every year. You might have stock in a company that makes food, but not in bananas because they’re inherently perishable - exactly like housing.

    Everyone should be wealthy, I can agree with that. And you’re right, it doesn’t have to be a house. But they have to be sufficiently wealthy that they have direct and meaningful control over their housing situation or it will breed contempt with the system - as we’re seeing around the world in the developed countries.

    I’m not talking about the right to change their housing, I’m talking about the power to which you e separated as the right and the liquidity. I’m talking about the combined power, so if you tell me they have one but not the other than for my intents and purposes they fail the necessary check that demonstrates if a society is working or not.


  • I’m not sure that correlation is actually useful as in a endstate capitalist society the more money per person that exists in the system the more imbalanced that money is distributed and thus you would assume as things got wealthier it would also get extracted from the working class. You can see this in all developed nations, but the US is a great example that I’m familiar with. They’ve made nothing but more money and more stuff more efficiently since the 1930s but as taxes on the wealthy were erroded and regulations kneecapped and Monopolies allowed (or defended) home ownership has plummeted. That’s not because homes got better, it’s because a postal worker in 1960 could afford their home and family without issue, and today a one income household is a fast route to poverty.

    No, I don’t like that correlation as an indicator of progress which I think is kinda what you’re implying. But I guess I could debate if everyone having their own home is a good thing, there might be something there. On the flip side I don’t think there’s value in debating if everyone owning their share of control over their housing. Everyone should absolutely control the state of their personal housing. The easiest way to achieve that is everyone owns their home/flat.





  • Can you imagine voting to improve your community and then the federal government tells you you can’t!? That’s insane. That’s how you radicalize people.

    “Protecting investments” should read clearly as taking money from working Germans to give to “Investors”. The CDU has always wanted to make our lives worse but this shows they also want to make sure we can’t make our lives better. This is who conservatives are everywhere. They’re not pro-business, as if they are financially more savvy. They’re pro-exploitation, they want the broken systems to keep functioning because they’re paid far more money keeping them broken than they personally would be to fix them.

    Don’t vote corrupt politicians into office, especially ones explicitly telling you they want to stop your life from getting better. But I guess that wouldn’t help Berlin here because they didn’t vote for these fuckers. This is has radicalization begins.


  • I think your responses to this are taking extreme theoretical positions that aren’t true. So for instance, the extreme theory of “I don’t support them because one of their (still financially connected) founders is a nazi” is “I must research all company’s I support for their political beliefs” and that’s not true - that’s an extreme stance.

    My real stance is “everyone should strive to be as ethical a consumer as they possibly can be - given their time, energy, and financial situations.” It’s not my job to research every company and I don’t have time/energy to research every provider of every product I consume; but I do what I can. It’s the job of the journalist to dig up these meaningful stories and distribute them to their community, that’s why that job is so important. And easily getting these stories distributed to me is why I’m on Lemmy (or back in the day reddit).

    So no, I do not have to research everyone to reduce my euros from going to Nazi’s. If my options are known Nazi or unknown something - I expect a reasonable person to always go with the unknown.

    And I do want to live in a society where Nazi beliefs have real life consequences, including and especially at work. The extreme stance is “all beliefs can be held against you at work” and that’s wrong. There’s a difference between a person wanting their government to tax them 2% less and a person wanting their government to expunge all black people to countries they may have never even visited. There’s a difference between being a part of the NRA and being a part of the KKK. You can be in party that worsens your country and your quality of life and makes the world slowly worse (like pre-trump modern republicans in the US or the CDU in Germany). You can’t be in party that is actively looking to dismantle civil rights, harm the out-groups, and make society rapidly worse (like Republicans, AfD, reform for britain, or the Nazi party).

    Everyone should want to live in a society where, if their coworkers are racist their company does something about it. Because that gets rid of racists at best or at worst it makes them sneakier - more quiet. Their has to be societal consequences for holding societally destructive beliefs. Should they starve? No. We should have Universal Basic Income. Should they be kicked out of their home? No, they should own their home and there shouldn’t be landlords. Should they be removed from any position of power and barred from ever holding one again? Yes, absolutely. They should be “tarred and feathered”, we should put a badge on them that says “dangerous and hateful” and we should treat them as such - they only get to hold jobs which can’t hurt other people they seek to hurt.

    There is a difference between ideas destructive to society and most normal ideas and you should want to treat them differently.


  • Hey, I’m a real person who organically discovered this news and made behavioral changes based on the news.

    I am not a nazi. I do not want to support nazi policies or beliefs or people who would strengthen and distribute Nazi policies or beliefs. If someone supports forcibly relocating citizens based off their bloodline history or the color of their present day skin, I think they should be as far away from a position of power as society can possibly manage while still treating them like a human.

    I believe, based on the Mullvad news, that one of the main benefactors if mullvad - meaning one of the guys who got a % for every euro I spent on the service - actively and meaningfully supports a national party with policies akin to Nazis. I want as much of my money to go to NOT-Nazis as possible, ideally 100%. So I left Mullvad for… I think it’s airvpn. Or ivpn actually, although I considered airvpn.

    I don’t think this is a crazy response. I also wish it was the overwhelmingly common response.