• 0 Posts
  • 35 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 3rd, 2023

help-circle



  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    2 days ago

    By that logic Hitler also did nothing wrong killing everyone that didn’t fit into his ideal system

    And that’s exactly my point, you can’t force your idea of an ideal system on a population

    It must be the other way round, a political system must be the result of its society, and not the society needs to be forced into the idea of a minority in power


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Well, one of them had a chance to actually change something and killed quite some people, while the other one wrote about a possible future we can work for

    But I already answered your private message, which I’m grateful for and look forward to our discussion

    Sorry that we can’t do this in public, so others could chime in and evaluate their own perspectives.

    But seems Summit is breaking down, if the thread has to many replies…

    Thanks again for reaching out privately, I’m looking forward to our discussion


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    I’m hijacking this comment, because my client seems to can’t manage so many replies - I’m sorry for everyone who tries to follow

    First of, thank you for the kind words, it’s currently really a hard time, so actually really thank you very much

    I already said it in an edit, because you recommend Stalin, I’m more aligned with Bakunin

    I don’t like people who killed thousands (or even more), because every life we lose is a loss in the general gene pool

    Just like we shouldn’t kill everything in nature, just because it favours our current economic
    We’re losing things of value with that, that could actually save us from future viruses or whatever

    Edit: and I invited you to work in a consensus between us, but you understood that as “I don’t want to talk anymore”
    Are you trolling me?


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    I’m sorry, I’m currently facing some hard stuff and maybe lose track easily, so this isn’t on purpose to win an argument or something

    All of our discussion lost a bit of track

    I’m currently privately not in a good place at the moment

    If you really want to talk and search for a consensus, then I’m open for that, but let’s do this in private messages

    Just message me and hopefully my client can work that out

    I don’t want to talk about the reasons, why I’m currently not in a good place, but trust me, it’s shit

    So, I’m open for philosophical/political discussions, but… I need to cancel that at the moment, sorry

    Edit: got your reply, but doesn’t matter if I want to answer directly or send you a private message, my client crashes (Summit)
    I’ll need to be up early to bring my partner to the hospital and just be strong for them, so I’d actually like to have this discussion on a real intellectual level, but with this combination of happening, I currently can’t, because I don’t have the time to check in with other clients - and also more important things are happening

    Still, I think, we two aren’t that far off ideological wise and we could work this out
    And maybe we can do this in the future

    Edit 2: thanks for the reading recommendations, maybe you could read some stuff from Bakunin





  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    3 days ago

    Of course it’s a class

    You have a ruling class that tries to distribute material for everyone in the best way it can - and that’s a very positive way of putting it, because everyone is corruptable

    I want to get rid of the necessary if this political class

    And I know, that this probably will need generations

    Edit: what if I’m not a worker, but an artist or a philosopher for example?


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Well, that’s the point, it’s not

    Communism is the dictatorship of the working class - you criticised me in my first comment because, I’m against the working class

    What I’m saying is, every political system, where a minority tells a majority how they need to live, it will lead to failure after time
    The smaller the leadership, the sooner the failure

    Every single individual needs to take responsibility of his life and his part in the society

    Because we’re are the fucking society we’re building by just living

    We just don’t need any rulers, and it doesn’t matter if it’s a communist ruler or a capitalist ruler - it’s still a ruler

    Let people be

    But we need education first.
    That’s why I said, that I’m an utopian and both of us will never see the fruits of our work, but we should still aim for anarchy

    If it’s communism or direct basic democracy, I don’t care.

    I care for the lone single individual



  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Then we would have a direct basic democracy

    No need for a class system and communism

    Edit: and existing so called communist parties did rule and kill

    And don’t see the same thing in the Anarchists summer of Spain for example


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    I think, we differ just in one point

    You think, that it’s inheritance in people, if being bad or good

    I don’t believe in bad or good, this are only momentarily social concepts

    You seem to believe that there can be a ruling class, that is good in principle
    I believe, ruling corrupts and no one should rule over anyone else

    I believe, that every human only wants to things: doing its will and … love

    Everything else is pathologic and needs to be treated

    I believe, that we can build a society, where everyone can do what his will is and be productive for everyone

    You say, we need a ruling party, that forces everyone into that - at least that’s how I understand it
    And that’s where my companionship breaks



  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    You seem to misunderstand my point, with a ruling communist party, you’ll have a ruling class, and that’s what I’m against

    I’m against classes as a principle, because we’re all humans and should be able to live free

    Doesn’t matter what the ruling party says - because fuck any ruling party, nobody needs to tell me how to live my life


  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Seems my lemmy client is crashing, if there are too many comments or something

    So I’m answering at a higher level

    Thank you, that you didn’t mean something bad, but calling me an enemy of the working class from the start, without even knowing what my political philosophy is, was something I took wrong immediately.

    I think, in principle we’re on the same side.

    But I think that having a political authoritan party, isn’t the end goal we should go for.

    As long as we have a minority in the ruling class, we will always have a class war.

    Doesn’t matter if it’s capitalism or communism.
    Either it’s ruling by money or in communism idea ruling by… Yeah, what?
    Doesn’t matter, it’s still ruling over people.

    I want the individual to be free.

    Maybe a dictatorship of the working class will be the step stone, maybe it will be something else.
    Time will tell

    Personally I’d go for direct basic democracy - maybe a bit like the pirate party proposes, but that’s something we have to work out together.

    What I want to say is, that communism isn’t the end goal, because then still people will be ruled

    I want educated, grown up people choosing their life and that society is a result of what this individuals are choosing to live by - politics is just the next layer that results of it

    It can’t be the other way round, that politics dictate my life

    That’s pretty much all of my philosophy and I’ll stand by it, because I’ll always be on the side of the little guy, who just wants to live his life.

    Not sure how anyone can be against this, because it would give everyone the most freedom of choice in their own live.



  • naeap@sopuli.xyzBanned from communitytoCommunism@lemmy.ml•Protestation
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    Nothing per se negative

    Depends if it’s political, social or in an environment, where authority is ok

    Like, maybe you are really good at making sculptures and I want to learn to do this as well.
    You’ll have natural authority over me, because you know it better and I want to learn from you.
    You’d be my teacher, I chose you and that’s fine.

    But if there is authority by political or social systems, that decline me to do what I my will is or want to decline my love to someone, because it doesn’t match the authority system (e.g. being gay), then I’ll fight you to death

    Easy as that

    Individual freedom trumps everything and society has to adapt
    Political systems are a result of society, so they also have to adapt

    But if political authority tells me, I can’t live how and love who I want, it will become a class again and we will have a fight

    So the hypothetical most positive society is the one, where everyone is free to do what their will is