

Ah I misunderstood the purpose. I thought it was to provide the community with a guide they could use to decide which games to support rather than a tool to condemn developers for their choices. Sorry for the misunderstanding.


Ah I misunderstood the purpose. I thought it was to provide the community with a guide they could use to decide which games to support rather than a tool to condemn developers for their choices. Sorry for the misunderstanding.


This is a good idea but I don’t think the current design adds much over existing categorization. There are already ways to find no-ai/handcrafted games. And complete slop is (at least for now) fairly obvious to spot. Imo the opportunity to refine the scale is all in the middle which you’ve collapsed into a single category.
I think most people who are willing to accept some ai use would benefit from a more nuanced approach. For instance, many people might be ok with some minor AI assistance in the programming process, but draw a hard line at ai assets. Your scale doesn’t serve those users.
I’m not arguing with your very valid points on the ethics and result of AI, just pointing out that to add utility past the current options you might need more granularity.
Also a major gray area is the use of libraries that may include ai code. For example, most games are now made with engines like unity, unreal, or godot. It’s almost certain that unity and unreal now include ai code. So can a game dev never use an engine again without falling into the tainted category? Do they have to write their own quaternary code for 3d translations, sprite blitter, texture mapper etc from scratch? What about using the windows API for file handling? That’s likely got ai code in it now. I guess to be considered handcrafted games need to be freebsd only now? Or ship with their own operating system?
I think we’d be better served by a scale like this:
0 - fully human made
0.5 - used a game engine / libraries / os SDK etc which likely includes AI generated code but is itself not considered total slop
1 - used some minor AI assisted coding techniques (e.g. code completions / merged an ai big fix after thorough review, etc)
2 - used extensive but human directed programming, assets all human made. Shows evidence of care put into design, graphics, story, etc
3 - vibe coded or close to it, but all assets still human made
4 - some ai assets, human directed work
5 - obviously totally vibe coded with generated assets


Yeah absolutely. I’ve seen that as well and it’s very concerning. You need layers of security. Especially if the private APN doesn’t have P2P traffic blocked, as otherwise a single field-compromised device becomes an ingress point.
Nonetheless, miles better than devices on the public net. Especially when compared to devices with public static IPs that don’t even have the protection of the carrier’s cg-nat.


That’s one of the two definitions, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_gap_(networking) And https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/air-gap
air-gapped networks are networks that have been isolated from all external networks, including cloud and wifi. Air-gapped networks are disconnected from the internet and provide a strong layer of protection from a broad range of cybersecurity threats.
In any case, pedantry aside the point stands that it’s possible to connect these in a way that’s isolated from the public internet.


You’re in your own VRF in the cellular ISP’s network. You typically get one or more RFC-1918 private subnets to assign IPs to your devices from. You can set strict ACLs on those devices. They have no internet access and can only communicate with each other (if you allow it) and optionally your network via carrier peering. The carrier peering is typically BGP over IPSEC or MPLS (although good old fashioned carrier hotel cross connects are also an option)
I’m assuming you were asking a serious question and so I provided a serious answer. Hopefully you find it interesting.
Source: I design cellular private networks for a living.


Can’t speak for the situation in other countries, but in the US as a business you can get a cheap lte modem and put it on a custom APN that’s completely airgapped (as in: inaccessible from the public internet) for less than $1/mo/sim with fairly minimal setup costs. So I agree, this is just silly that these are on public networks.
Original welcome email on my Gmail October 2005.
Subject was “Gmail is different. Here’s what you need to know.”
I would actually argue that there is some validity to scrutinizing code supply chain. For example a dev could choose to a human-crafted library in c++ or use a vibe-coded “port” to rust or whatever because that’s the language they’re more familiar with. Those choices are worth investigating.