• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle


  • Based off of the information provided in only the OP, yeah I probably would take it if was in their position. I don’t see anything morally wrong with literally being paid for providing industry training for specialized skills for machine learning.

    Everyone bitches like “I want AI to do the dishes for me so I can do art, not do art for me so I can do dishes” yeah that’s a legit feeling but the reality is that there was tons of art to steal to train models on and zero data about how your body moves when you’re doing dishes to train models on. So we got art and writing and music theft and the destruction of web search, because all that information was available and easy to steal. When I say FUCK AI that’s what I’m talking about, along with all the other disgusting business practices across the board.

    Being paid to train machine learning models to do your job in the future isn’t selling out. Tech moves on, jobs go away. It’s the HOW that evolution happens that we should cast moral judgement on, not the fact that it happens in the first place.


  • eye roll Get it that this isn’t the right place for a nuanced discussion on this, or probably even the right platform, but I’ll say it anyways.

    Congress is complicit in the grand theft of IP by not stopping it in its tracks. So is every employee that did the theft itself, every lawyer that helped arrange the financial details, etc. All the big data collection companies that sold your info are complicit in the rape of your privacy.

    But the fact is that there are real technological innovations with the advent of modern machine learning, and it’s dumb to lump the march of innovation in with all the worst parts of whatever “AI” is.

    OP isn’t complicit in the obsolescence of the actual work he does - that’s falsely assigning judgement and negative connotation to a plain fact: the industry he works in is changing. Eventually there will be many fewer machinists that do the work he does, and AI will do a lot of the work that used to be done by human machinists. That in and of itself isn’t a good or bad thing (it just IS), even if there’s TONS of negative externalities (environmental, economic control, loss of jobs, whatever). So no, OP isn’t complicit in some downfall of his industry if he sells his knowledge to train AI models.

    Now, if he stole this data from employees in a company or something and sold it, he would be complicit in the theft of that information. But not necessarily the industry change that is coming.


  • It’s going to happen anyways. You’re not complicit in what’s happening if you take advantage of this opportunity that’s presented itself to you.

    This is a new industrial revolution, and it’s going to displace jobs like yours. It sucks, but it’s happening.

    There’s a shit load of theft and awful stuff happening right now and that’s abhorrent, but paying you for data is 100% legit and how every author and artist etc should have been compensated for the training data that’s gone into the machine learning black hole.

    At the end of the day it’s up to you, but I wouldn’t worry about this one. They’re paying you for legitimate use. Eventually folks like yourself will be much rarer/specialized.