Bravo, Linus.
What does Linus envision Linux to be? A slop-ware? A project managed by GAFAM via LLMs?
Does Linus seriously think that slop puts him (or his colleagues) in control?
No, it does not.
Humans with skills keep quitting, Stoakes is even vocal about the reasons.
Others leave more quietly.
Linux advocates should be deeply concerned. Linus caught the ‘brain virus’. █
“LLMs don’t join unions or speak up at meetings, thus it about control, just like the rest of the fight(s) about software freedom” -Anonymous
Yeah this seems to be misreported and a biased post?
It links to quotes of Lorenzo Stoakes own posts, and he says hes stepping down due to the volume of AI submitted changes he is now having to wade through, and wanting to free himself up from that work. He also says he’s going to continue to contribute to the kernal. No where does it mention Linux Torvaldes or quitting the linux kernel.
He doesnt say its because of Linus’ “obsession with slop”? Its conflating the persons reasons for stepping back (which is undoubtedly at least in part related to AI slop) and Linus Torvaldes position on AI, and making it seem like the guy is specifically quitting over that? Its misrepresentation of the facts.
There is a story here but its being presented as a personal repudiation of Linux Torvaldes (presumably the post authors view), rather than a more nuanced story around dealing with AI in open source projects.
The post writer is welcome to their views, but representing them as if they are Lorenzo Stoakes views is wrong.
Given the current throughput in the kernel resulting from AI-generated series, I unfortunately lack the bandwidth to generally be able to offer review except in those areas I maintain.
He is not quitting though, just prioritizing his time.
I really hope all the tech workers quitting over AI are in contact with each other. That’s an incredible amount of talent and labor power just waiting to be harnessed.
Yeah I’ve been hoping for a Linus-free kernel fork ever since Torvalds drank the Kool-Aid. He’s lost.
I’m not watching two hours of video. Provide evidence that Torvalds is “obsessed with slop”.
He says it himself. He loves the shit out of AI.
“I’m not engaging with the source providing the evidence. Also, where is the evidence??”
Evidence needs to be accessible. A 2 hour video is not accessible. Especially since it doesn’t even seem to play when I tried to find it.
Yeah but that’s a 2 hours video, to watch to know about maybe 20 lines of Linus’ emails?
I have an idea, maybe I can use some new technology to transcribe the video, and summarize it.
Does such a technology exist?
From a practical standpoint: as long as the applications my end users care about run, the OS underneath is meaningless. If they go in a direction that causes those vendors to migrate to BSD/Windows we’ll migrate with them. If WSL 9p fs performance improves to a sufficient level, it could take that workload as well (and it’s getting closer).
There’s nobody stopping the community from forking a slip-free kernel, but that’s a huge time commitment in and of itself.
When Linux maintainers - and most open-source contributors, including yours truly - walk off, and the Linux project goes to shit, you and your end users will start caring. And it’ll be too late.




